Monday, 2 October 2023

Trolley 590

Was captured in an obscure corner of the multi storey car park behind Waitrose. A car park which is probably swept for trolleys, perhaps on a daily basis, but maybe the sweep does not reach this particular corner. A corner which, as it happened, appeared to cater mostly for special needs.

A slightly battered trolley, not very new, from the M&S food hall.

On the way to the car park, I had stopped in Rosebery Park, underneath a spreading tree, I think of the acer family. But not a sycamore. The point of present interest being that the flats at the back, overlooking the park, looked far bigger in real life than they do in the snap above - and I completely failed to work out why. The field of view of the eyes and that of the telephone were approximately the same, although it was hard to be sure. The telephone preserved intersections, that is to say if the path crossed the tree, the point of crossing was the same for the telephone and the eyes, give or take a bit of adjustment for the lens of the telephone being a few inches in front of the lenses of the eyes.

Maybe I could devise some experiment involving string and an assistant to probe what is going on here. Practise at home and then see what interest I could attract in the park. But then, I never followed up a similar post at reference 2, so maybe not.

Having delivered the trolley to M&S, onto to Waitrose, where apart from feeling the cold off all the chiller cabinets, I fell for some kippers to go with the Savoy cabbage I had been commissioned to buy, the larder being a trifle bare after our western expedition. Kippers which turned out very well. Simmered for ten minutes or so in plenty of water: grilling was the thing when I was young, but I find that too salty these days. 

Waitrose could also do a Guardian and a TLS. Both turning out to be quite good numbers. With the TLS not being very reliable at all these days, often containing far too much literature for my taste. Name notwithstanding.

Then off up West Hill, passing on the way a smallish middle aged man with a large bulldog, not on its lead, although he was holding the lead. I thought a man who, for reasons best known to himself, was challenging the world to have a go at him for having a large and potentially dangerous dog off its lead in a reasonably busy town. I did not rise to the challenge and I shall keep my thoughts about the man and his dog to myself.

Home to read about a proposal to turn the upstairs of the hardware store snapped from gmaps above, presently closed, into a flat with a patio left, more or less above and behind where it says 'EPSOM'. It seems that some heritage people thought that such a patio would infringe the privacy of people who might be taking beverages on the Wetherspoon's patio far left and that of people who might be wandering about the market square. On this occasion they were overruled by the planning people. And to think that I used to rather like taking a beverage on the Wetherspoon's terrace overlooking the platform 9 part of Victoria Station. All kinds of entertaining, early evening goings on to be seen.

PS 1: I think the last real kipper I had in a restaurant was in the Ardlui Hotel at the northern end of Loch Lomond. They were grilled, but vastly better than the plastic bagged yellow mush which passes for kippers in the few hotels down south that still serve them. At least the sort of hotels that we use. Posh hotel in London? I also remember there was a time when you could get real kippers for breakfast on trains, but I guess that is just showing my age.

PS 2: and should you happen to stay in the Ardlui Hotel in the winter, do not attempt to drive south on the A82 when the low winter sun is anywhere near south. A mistake which I made, and which made for a rather uncomfortable hour or so.

References

Reference 1: https://psmv5.blogspot.com/2023/09/trolley-589.html.

Reference 2: https://psmv3.blogspot.com/2016/05/lies.html.

Reference 3: https://ardlui.com/.

Group search key: trolleysk.

Bad apples

This from the same stable as the Swampman of reference 3. A digression from reference 2, where reference 2 cropped up in reference 1, where reference 1 is a chance find turned up by Bing when I was on some errand or other – and which has been keeping me busy for the past few weeks.

Another thought experiment

What about if I lose or don’t have the ability to consciously smell some particular smell – while keeping the ability to detect it unconsciously? A smelly, if limited, version of the blindsight of reference 4. What is consciousness bringing to this party? Does this experiment offer any clues as to what consciousness is for?

Let us suppose that:

We humans have evolved enough to have language. We can talk about stuff.

All talk is conscious, with subjective experience. Which is a bit of a simplification.

A lot of thought uses language; a sort of suppressed speech, speech which does not seen the light of day.

Smells arise from things – often wet things – giving off volatile chemicals which can be detected by the human nose. We might allow a many-to-many relationship between chemicals and smells, rather than the simpler one-to-one.

The nose works by having lots of surface detectors, each of which is tuned to a particular chemical. The repertoire of detectors is genetically determined and varies, usually slightly, from person to person.

The experience of smell is the product of the signal from the nose combined with context and memory. Some smells usually have a negative valence, possibly disgust, and other smells have a positive valence, often pleasure. The former is presumably, inter alia, a way of stopping us eating decayed or rotten food. Or at least of slowing us down while we think about it.

Smells are used for a variety of signalling purposes. Some of these are to do with food and drink, some are to do with sex and some are to do with other aspects of behaviour.

Sometimes I might give out smells unwanted, perhaps the smell of fear. At other times I might be able, I might choose, to disguise the way I smell with perfumes or whatever.

Let us further suppose that:

Apples are an important part of the diet of the group in which I am living.

One day something happens, with some apples becoming poisonous and being reliably marked by a particular smell. Not poisonous as in fatal, just poisonous in the sense of causing serious stomach upsets or indigestion. Not the same as the smell of over-ripe or rotten apples. Loosely, in what follows, the smell of bad apples.

Being poisonous is not a property of an individual apple tree, rather of an individual apple. Previous apples from a tree do not reliably predict the next apple from that same tree.

This smell survives preparing the apple, cutting it up and peeling it, but does not survive cooking. Although the poison does so survive.

My nose can detect this smell and pass the necessary information to the brain, but for some reason the smell does not become conscious. Option 1: this smell does not make it to consciousness at all; as far as that is concerned the apple is odourless. Option 2: this smell is assimilated to some other smell. We stick with option 1.

Contexts in which I might want to be able to smell:

Apples on the tree, perhaps in an orchard. Which ones do I pick, which ones do I leave or discard?

Apples in store, perhaps in an apple loft.

Apples on a belt in a packing station.

Apples exhibited for sale, loose in a box or basket.

Apples exhibited for sale in a more or less sealed packet.

Apples in a bowl in someone’s house, or in a hotel or restaurant.

Cooked apples in a prepared dish in someone’s house or in a hotel or restaurant.

The question:

Given all this, the question is: what do I lose by not being able to smell this particular smell of bad apples? In what follows I address this question under various heads.

Missing out

I might well know about this smell, but I would not be experiencing it. I would be missing out on an experience which most people had. But then, there are lots of experiences out there which I am not going to have. To take a rather extreme example, if I am a man, I can’t experience being a mother. Less extreme, if I don’t work on an in-door building site, I am never going to experience their distinctive smell of dust, cement and concrete.

I might know about these experiences, but I can’t or don’t actually have them. A distinction that I shall be coming back to in a post to come about what I call the ‘Mary knew’ story, another thought experiment, not of my own manufacture, rather to be found at reference 2.

But missing out on one or two minor experiences is not really that important, not really a problem in itself – unless, perhaps, in this case, I wanted to be a serious player in the apple business.

Then there is the other sort of missing out, possibly more important to me, of not being able to do things the way that everyone else does them. Not being part of the group, at least in so as far as this is concerned. And quite apart from my feelings about it, there is a loss of efficiency, a loss of biological fitness: things work much better if we all have more or less the same equipment.

Vague feelings and their problems

Given that the bad smell is reaching my brain, I might well have vague feelings about bad apples, even though I was not conscious of their bad smell. In the absence of smell, I might act on these feelings, perhaps getting lots of false positives and lots of false negatives along the way - but still doing a lot better than chance on a blind trial.

Vague feelings could be caused by all sorts of things and I might never know which. But would this matter? I just went with my gut feeling (as they say in detective soaps) and hoped for the best. It is not as if this apple business is that important.

Conscious smell is fast and reliable: one could work on an apple sorting and packing line on the basis of smell – but not on the basis of vague feelings of aversion – which are neither fast nor reliable.

The suggestion above is that unconscious action is going to be inferior to conscious action. Which is plausible, but where is the evidence? There is evidence that some complex actions, such as hitting a golf ball into a distant hole, are better performed more or less unconsciously – to which one might respond that conscious learning has to precede such unconscious action. 

And it might well be that the ladies on the packing line, the ones who have the smell, do sort their apples more or less unconsciously, with the work only rising to consciousness when there is some problem, some interrupt – while most of the time gossiping about more important matters with the ladies on either side.

More generally, one can argue that the unconscious brain manages everything quite happily without troubling the conscious brain, that consciousness is just a bit of froth on top of the real business. An epiphenomenon in the jargon of the trade. And that, in the case of the apples, I learn to let the unconscious brain get on with it, without attempting to interfere. For the present, we do not allow this possibility.

Instead, we suggest that it takes the power conferred by making this smell conscious to make it possible to link the smell to the notion of bad apple. It is not possible to link the diffuse pre-conscious smell activity in the brain to any notion, let alone this one.

A speculation

In this speculation, we use the convention that neural activation proceeds from upstream to downstream. From, for example, the eye to the subjective image of an apple. Roughly, from left to right in the snap above.

The smell of the bad apple, the bad apple smell, activates a whole lot of upstream neurons.

With the general drift of processing being to reduce the number of dimensions, to reduce the rather chaotic original input from the nose to something which more or less codes for a known smell: the smell itself (rather in the way of pointing out a colour in a colour chart from a paint manufacturer), its intensity and where it is coming from. Maybe other stuff.

Put another way, this activation works its way downstream to the bad apple smell location (SL). The brain has worked out that this in-bound smell is the bad apple smell that it already knows about.

The sight of the bad apple activates another lot of upstream neurons.

The activation works its way down to a bit of more transient memory which carries the image of this particular apple, the source of the smell, the bad apple location (AL). 

The first binding then ties these two up with negative valence (NV). Which implies we have got into the multi-modal part of the brain which can process input from all the senses.

The second binding then ties the bad apple location (AL), to the negative valence (NV) and avoidance action (AA). And from thence down the spinal cord for some actual action. The negative valence being a convenient, short-hand bridge between the two bindings. Rather as valence is a convenient short-hand generally: I register something out there as bad and so avoid it, without needing to trouble myself why – I just get on with the appropriate action. A short-hand widely used by parents the world over: it is often much easier and more effective to say that something is bad than to go to all the bother of explaining why something is bad. Widely used by Christian priests when they drum the ten commandments into children at Sunday school.

The present suggestion is that all this requires data integration of the same sort as that required to make a summary of that data conscious. So it is plausible that it is all bound up together.

Action in mitigation of this smell not being conscious

That is to say, various coping strategies which improve on both just avoiding apples altogether and having to rely on those vague feelings – which we suppose to be inferior to smell, to be less reliable than smell. If I really cared, I would work at the issue.

First, work at finding properties of the apple which amounted to smell and to which I did have access. Properties would include both properties of the apple itself and properties of its circumstances. Perhaps where it had been grown or where it had been packed and stored.

Second, work at the vague feelings, get them tuned up, perhaps working with heaps of apples which had been sorted by someone else into good and bad. Which work might, possibly, result in my being able to smell the bad apples after all. Maybe not as well as I ought, but better than not at all.

Work which would go better if I could talk about the whole business both with people who could smell the bad apples and people who could not. A point covered by the first supposition above. Consciousness good, consciousness plus language better.

If I were a Roman emperor, I could take a suitable slave about with me to smell out the bad apples for me. And I could do something of the sort without being an emperor, just taking someone with me when I went shopping for apples.

If I were very rich, I could persuade a medical instrument company to make me a gadget which could detect the smell by pointing it at a bad apple.

Dealing with cooked apples

If apples were offered in cooked form, either I have to be the cook and have taken appropriate precautions – or I would have to be able to trust the cook or restaurant. As would someone who could smell the bad apples before they were cooked – but at least they would be able to check apples in their own kitchens for themselves.

Other advantages of this smell being conscious

Conscious smell is a reason for doing something. A reason which can be talked about, perhaps put aside. A conscious smell gets into memory where I can likely get hold of and use the information.

An older person can teach a younger person about a conscious smell. And while this smell needs to be conscious, it doesn’t need to be labelled. The older person can just say: ‘do not eat apples which smell like this one’. A next step might be to call it the bad apple smell – leaving aside the complication that there might be more than one such smell

Summary

All a bit woolly, but the story seems to be that, other things being equal, I would be able to do better if I were conscious of the smell and able to talk about it than otherwise.

Perhaps one would be able to be more definite if one knew more about the details of smell processing within the brain and those of linking the results of that processing to action.

Maybe one of the functions of consciousness, is to make stuff available for communication with others? Communication which can be hugely productive, which can hugely improve our collective fitness. Which would be more convincing if one were to explain why speech needed to be conscious – which is clearly not the case with the sort of talking robot we have today.

References

Reference 1: The nature of qualia: a neurophilosophical analysis – Carlos E B de Sousa – 2009. 

Reference 2: Epiphenomenal qualia – Jackson F – 1982.

Reference 3: https://psmv5.blogspot.com/2023/09/swampman.html. 

Reference 4: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blindsight. 

Reference 5: https://www.fastcompany.com/1822338/what-good-bosses-do-bad-apples. The source of the apple snap, turned up by Bing. I liked the snappy advice to management: ‘when in doubt, take it out’. The idea being that good bosses have a subtraction mindset and continually search for things to remove and simplify – and ways to make life less frustrating and annoying.

Sunday, 1 October 2023

Another Devon delicacy

This time a hog's pudding, from Bidders the butcher, to be found between the petrol station and the co-op, Moorland Villas, Yelverton. The chap from whom I sometimes buy groats or white pudding for a change.

He also sold the runner beans, probably from some nearby garden, which we have not had for a while and which turned out very well. Peeled back and front and no strings at all. Could have done with a few more really, the 750g not going as far prepared and cooked as one might think from the raw.

Pudding sliced and lightly fried on both sides. BH did not take the casing off which would probably have resulted in damage, but it was easy enough to remove from the cooked slices. She did three of the four puddings I had bought, which all went, with the fourth serving for (white bread) sandwiches for breakfast a day or so later.

References

Reference 1: https://psmv4.blogspot.com/2020/10/food-in-devon-second-day.html. A previous encounter with Bidders. The hutch is still there.

A Devon delicacy

We had occasion in Dawlish last week to partake of that Devon delicacy known as a fish finger sandwich. Served with skinny fries, a dollop of green salad and a dollop of white salad. Supplied by the Beach Bar, appropriately just a short step from the beach. Just nip under the railway line and you are there.

I did not bother with the salads, but the sandwich and accompanying chips were rather good. A substantial snack. And as with bacon sandwiches, you do need factory sliced white to bring out the full flavour. Not the same at all with proper bread or fancy bread. It was not appropriate at the time, but the establishment is also fully licensed and is quite possibly busy on summer evenings.

I dare say that if you asked for such a thing at the rather fancier restaurant at reference 1, to be found at Lyme Regis, you would get hand crafted goujons of locally caught rock salmon or something, rather than whatever falls off the lorry from Bidfood, that is to say principal supplier to the casual dining industry. But I very much doubt if the result would be worth the very large amount that they would undoubtedly charge. Particularly if they opted for some multi-grain, sour-dough bread instead of factory white.

PS 1: having said that, I remember once, many years ago, reading of someone who thought it would be fun to march into the main restaurant at the Savoy Hotel and call for a bacon and egg sandwich. There, so the story ran, the sandwich was excellent, well up to the standard of the Market Restaurant of Whitecross Street, an establishment mentioned in these pages from time to time.

PS 2: Mr. Wylde can't be all bad. His offering appears to include fake clasp knives from Laguiole, also mentioned in these pages from time to time. Not least for causing the security chaps on Eurostar a frisson. See, for example, references 3, 4 and 5.

PS 3: we were interested to see that square plates have made it across the Exe and down to Dawlish.

References

Reference 1: https://www.robinwylde.com/.

Reference 2: https://www.bidfood.co.uk/.

Reference 3: https://psmv5.blogspot.com/2023/04/fake-157.html.

Reference 4: https://pumpkinstrokemarrow.blogspot.com/2010/06/dts.html. A post which, although I say it myself, appears to have stood the test of time fairly well. With apologies to the various kind and pleasant nurses who help me along my way. I have not had a lecture yet!

Reference 5: https://www.couteau-laguiole.com/en/.

Back on board

My first task after regaining the airwaves yesterday was to move a modest number - two or three - snaps from my telephone to somewhere visible from my laptop.

The first attempt was confused by what seemed like a change to the sharing tool provided by Samsung, whereby I was no longer able to use gmail to effect the transfer. The second attempt involved gdrive and that seems to have got lost in the ether. The third attempt (this Sunday morning) also involved gdrive and so far has only resulted in a notification appearing in gdrive on my telephone which I cannot access.

My second task was to track down the last time I noticed the bizarre custom in the US whereby the government runs out of money at about this time of year and all kinds of things have to be shut down, a custom which I feel certain I have noticed before. I failed on this task also, although I have learned that some deal has been struck, a deal which leaves out, for the present at least, continuing aid to the Ukraine. Maybe Europe is going to have to step up to the plate.

Having failed on the first two tasks, I thought a bit of relaxation with a YouGov survey was in order. The first part of which was a long stream of questions about social media. Their computer was clearly not very impressed with my answers as substantive questions were interspersed with ones like that snapped above, checking that I was still awake. While I was not very impressed as what seemed like a large proportion of the questions did not include appropriate cop-out answers like 'don't know' or 'not applicable', so forcing me to give answers which were either simply untrue or a guess. For example, by not including the answer 'never' to the question 'when did you last use tiktak' or not including the answer 'don't know' to the question 'do you think that tiktoe is more socially responsible that flipflop' - when you have not heard of either. Perhaps they call this 'forced choice' and think that they can extract useful information from me in this way. Not the sort of thing that the very serious people of the Government Social Survey would go in for when I had contact with them - although, to be fair, that was quite a long time ago - and a quick search suggests that this once highly respected organisation no longer exists.

This stream of questions went on for rather a long time and I was getting a bit fed up, when the computer changed tack and started on another long stream of questions about something else. At this point I shut the window down and I presume that all that useful information was lost to the world. Perhaps I really am collecting too many black marks and will be struck off the YouGov panel for not playing the game.

At which point I remembered that the co-inventor of YouGov was, at least until recently, one of the rising stars of the Conservative Party, one Nadhim Zahawi, for who see reference 2.

PS 1: failed by one minute to slip this post into the dying minutes of Saturday. So all in all, a most unsatisfactory start to the morning.

PS 2: I suppose that I should not talk about black marks any more. Maybe I should suggest to Mr. Starmer that when he gets into power that he should set up a quango to advise on expelling all this bad language, to come up with replacements for all offending locutions. Perhaps chaired by some Oxford professor with some resounding title. I associate to the French quango which has the similarly unenviable task of clearing out all the useful English phrases from their language.

PS 3: how about the Gorley Putt Professor of Poetry and Poetics in the Faculty of English at Cambridge University, Cambridge? For which see reference 4.

References

Reference 1: US lawmakers pass short-term deal to avoid government shutdown: Agreement to maintain funding until mid-November leaves out billions of dollars in Ukraine aid - Lauren Fedor, Colby Smith, James Politi, Financial Times - 2023.

Reference 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nadhim_Zahawi.

Reference 3: https://psmv5.blogspot.com/2023/07/fake-165.html. A previous outing for YouGov.

Reference 4: https://pumpkinstrokemarrow.blogspot.com/2011/02/mubaraks-2.html.

Group search key: US, government, congress, money, shutdown, shut, down.

Saturday, 23 September 2023

More Schubert

The stringed Schubert noticed at reference 1 was followed up a couple of days later by some keyed Schubert, D960, from one Ignas Maknickas, a young man just starting out on his career. So has not yet acquired a page on Wikipedia, but he does have the web site at reference 2, from which I learn he was born in California in 1998 and was raised in Lithuania, presumably the country of origin of at least one of his parents.

An overcast day, and after deep thought I decided to take the tube there, rather than cycle over from Waterloo, which is what I would have done not so many years ago.

So train to Vauxhall, where there were lots of cricket types milling about. Mainly male, middle aged and middle classed. Not a tinny to be seen anywhere; if present, all neatly tucked away into their neat little bags and rucksacks. Plus summery shirts and hats. While the tube was very hot, and seemed very hot indeed by the time that I got to Oxford Circus. I would not have cared to spend much time down there, let alone do any work.

An art work carved into the entrance of an office block in Regent Street, a lot better in real life than it appears above. See references 3 and 4.

The margins of Cavendish Square were looking a little unkempt. Not helped by some of their box trim being struck down in the same way as our own box back in Epsom.

A light lunch on a bench consisting of a thin slice of home-baked brown, without butter or cheese on this occasion. Maybe a mouth full of water. 

From there to the Wigmore Hall, perhaps a third to a half full. Same flowers as on the Sunday, starting to look a bit tired.

The stocking filler from Remesa was short and not without interest. with Remesa being a Lithuanian with a Wikipedia page in Lithuanian. While the Schubert had a slightly metallic sound to it and seemed very fast. Sometimes a bit of the background got a bit lost behind all the goings on in the foreground. All of which might have been the youth of the executant or might have been my lack of sleep the night before. But good all the same. And oddly, afterwards I felt much refreshed; the lack of sleep had been blown away.

There was also a short encore. Not terribly appropriate to my mind, but had the virtue of being very short.

As it happened, I was reminded a few days later that the performers like these stocking fillers; they provide a bit of welcome variety from the stuff the punters come to hear, stuff which they have probably played time after time. But they have the good sense not to include too much filler, which might put the paying punters off.

From there to Hinde Street to pull a Bullingdon to take me down to Old Compton Street, via Soho Square, to buy cheese. I had to cheat a bit to take a right off Oxford Street.

A litter of hire bikes somewhere along the way. I find them very irritating, but I imagine that I would be wasting my time if I were to write a moaning letter to the Mayor of London about them. More important things to worry about.

Cheese bought - Lincolnshire Poacher again - on to Drury Lane and from there down to Waterloo. On the roundabout a large black transit van with a passenger in army uniform. What were they up to? And just behind the stand snapped above we had four students practising their jumps around the top of the stairs. Two of each sex.

From there, a short visit to the Hole in the Wall, a house I used to use reasonably regularly once, before Youngs gathered it into their family. But I was pleased to find that it had not changed much and was still a slightly scruffy boozer.

The penultimate item was some full-on young people a few seats away from me on the train. Maybe they were wannabee creatives. A bit tiring for us pensioners.

While the outing wound up with the haul snapped above from the Raynes Park platform library. The ancient romance bottom right for BH was rapidly discarded. The thriller top right was noticed at reference 5. While left we have a rather odd cycling magazine, this number of which was devoted to lady cyclists. Lots of arty pictures of ladies, their cycles and parts of their cycles. Haven't really got to grips with it yet.

References

Reference 1: https://psmv5.blogspot.com/2023/09/death-and-maiden-not.html.

Reference 2: https://www.ignasmaknickas.com/.

Reference 3: Line - Vone Phaophanit and Claire Oboussier - 2014.

Reference 4: https://atopia.org.uk/commission/line/. The creatives - who, seemingly, have tapped into the corporate market for art.

Reference 5: https://psmv5.blogspot.com/2023/09/jack-finney.html.

Thursday, 21 September 2023

Wasps?

This ivy seemed alive with wasps again around noon earlier today, warm with the sun out. But they don't seem to have survived the Samsung treatment, and I can only find five or six when I zoom in. Perhaps it is the lack of movement which makes them hard to pick out.

I say wasps, but BH, who was not there on this occasion, seems to think bees are more likely. I asked Bard but he was not particularly helpful although I did learn that:

'Bees are pollinators, and they rely on flowers for food. Ivy blooms in the late fall, when many other flowers have died back. Bees are attracted to ivy's nectar and pollen, and they play an important role in pollinating this plant.

Wasps are predators and scavengers. They eat other insects, spiders, and nectar. Wasps are attracted to ivy's nectar, but they are not as dependent on it as bees. Wasps are also more likely to be active in the heat of the day, while bees are more active in the morning and evening'.

Checking, I find a distinction between what wasps eat and what they feed their larvae, who can, it seems, deal with a wider variety of solid food than the adult. Something which Bard did not think to mention, although he did think that I was interested in wasp stings.

And then his logic seemed to fail on my follow-up.

All that said, my rather dim memory of getting for twelve hours ago, does not include the bright yellow and black striped abdomens with pointed ends that I associate with wasps. So my money is on bees - but not the bumble sort.

PS: mid-afternoon on Friday, that is to say the following day, we came across some more busy ivy, not far from junction 17 on the M4. And BH was quite clear on this occasion that it was bees.

References

Reference 1: https://psmv5.blogspot.com/2023/09/skinner.html. Previous notice.